Widely agreedMaison Alhambra
Yeah
It is close to the original but more synthetic and does not last a full workday.

Yves Saint Laurent
4 fragrances are widely sold as cheaper versions of this. Ranked strongest match first.
Like a crisp apple and ginger fizz with sage and juniper, drying down to warm amberwood and cedar
Main accords: aromatic, woody, fresh spicy, warm spicy, amber, fruity. 2018 · Eau de Parfum
Widely agreedMaison Alhambra
Yeah
It is close to the original but more synthetic and does not last a full workday.
Widely agreedArmaf
Odyssey Mega
On point enough to beat the original in a blind test — one owner had his wife compare them and she picked this as the real one, and preferred it. He wears the original daily as his signature. The original probably still edges it on longevity. The atomiser is the one thing everybody complains about.
Widely agreedLattafa
Sheikh Al Shuyukh Final Edition
It lasts longer but smells more herbal because of its lemongrass and rose.
Often citedArmaf
Odyssey Mega Limited Edition
It is fruitier and smoother than the original.
Ranking combines how widely wearers agree a fragrance is a dupe with how closely its notes and accords line up. “Strong match” means both signals agree; “loose match” means it is in the same family but noticeably different on skin. 4 of these link to a published source.
Maison Alhambra Yeah is widely sold as a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y. It is close to the original but more synthetic and does not last a full workday.
Armaf Odyssey Mega is widely sold as a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y. On point enough to beat the original in a blind test — one owner had his wife compare them and she picked this as the real one, and preferred it. He wears the original daily as his signature. The original probably still edges it on longevity. The atomiser is the one thing everybody complains about.
Lattafa Sheikh Al Shuyukh Final Edition is widely sold as a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y. It lasts longer but smells more herbal because of its lemongrass and rose.
Armaf Odyssey Mega Limited Edition is widely sold as a dupe of Yves Saint Laurent Y. It is fruitier and smoother than the original.
Maison Alhambra Yeah is the closest we have on record. It is the one wearers name most consistently. It is close to the original but more synthetic and does not last a full workday.
Yes — 4 of them, including Maison Alhambra Yeah, Armaf Odyssey Mega, Lattafa Sheikh Al Shuyukh Final Edition. Each is listed above with what it gets right and where it falls short.
No. A dupe is built to the same idea, not the same formula, and cheaper materials usually show in the opening and in how long it lasts. That is why every entry here says how it differs instead of giving a percentage. Of Maison Alhambra Yeah, for instance: It is close to the original but more synthetic and does not last a full workday.
Like a crisp apple and ginger fizz with sage and juniper, drying down to warm amberwood and cedar It opens on Apple, Ginger, Bergamot.
Y Eau de Parfum is the fragrance that repositioned Yves Saint Laurent as a serious contender in contemporary men's perfumery. Released in 2018 as a more intense follow-up to the 2017 Y Eau de Toilette, it quickly eclipsed its predecessor to become one of the most popular designer masculines of the late 2010s — a crowd-pleasing aromatic woody composition that manages to be both mass-appealing and genuinely well-constructed.
The opening is bright and immediately likeable. Apple provides a crisp, green-tinged sweetness that gives the first impression a youthful, fresh quality. Ginger adds a warm, peppery spice that prevents the apple from becoming too simple or fruity, while bergamot contributes the classic citrus refinement that grounds the composition in the YSL tradition of European elegance. The combination is energetic and optimistic — the olfactory equivalent of a confident stride down a city street on a clear autumn morning.
The heart is where Y EDP begins to show its depth. Sage provides a dry, herbal warmth with slightly camphoraceous overtones, while juniper berries add a gin-like, resinous freshness that reinforces the aromatic character. Geranium contributes a rosy, slightly minty quality that bridges the gap between the fresh opening and the warm base. These aromatic herbs give Y its distinctive character — it smells cleaner and more natural than many of its synthetic-heavy competitors, with a green, almost outdoorsy quality that suggests forests and open air rather than laboratories.
The base provides the warmth and longevity that justify the Eau de Parfum concentration. Amberwood — a warm, slightly sweet synthetic that has become a staple of modern masculine perfumery — forms the backbone of the drydown, providing a golden, resinous warmth. Cedar adds dry, pencil-shaving elegance, while vetiver contributes earthy, smoky depth. Tonka bean rounds the base with its sweet, coumarin-rich warmth, and olibanum — frankincense — adds a quietly spiritual, incense-like quality that elevates the composition beyond simple crowd-pleaser territory. This incense note is subtle but important; it is the element that gives Y EDP its sense of sophistication and separates it from countless other fresh-woody-amber designer masculines.
The dominant aromatic and woody accords, with prominent fresh spicy, warm spicy, amber, and fruity notes, create a fragrance that is both contemporary and timeless. The moderate fresh, citrus, gourmand, herbal, and green qualities ensure enough complexity to sustain interest through a full day of wear.
Y EDP succeeded because it struck the perfect balance between approachability and quality. It does not challenge or provoke — it pleases, consistently and reliably. But within that crowd-pleasing framework, there is genuine craftsmanship: the herbal heart, the frankincense base, the careful calibration of sweetness against freshness all speak to a composition designed with care rather than assembled by algorithm.
As an Eau de Parfum with long lasting longevity and strong sillage, Y projects confidently without being overbearing. It is a true four-season fragrance, equally comfortable in summer heat and winter cold, at the office or on a weekend date. Four to five sprays provide all-day presence with a warm, aromatic trail that consistently draws compliments. It is the everyday signature scent for the modern man who wants to smell excellent without thinking too hard about it.