Widely agreedFragrance World
Music Fest
Around 75 to 80 percent there — not a one-to-one, but it lands the boozy tobacco the original is loved for, and comes across stronger and more cognac-heavy. Reports on longevity contradict each other.

Maison Margiela
One fragrance is widely sold as a cheaper version of this. Ranked strongest match first.
Rum and tobacco with vanilla underneath — warm, boozy, like an old bar at closing time.
2013
Widely agreedFragrance World
Music Fest
Around 75 to 80 percent there — not a one-to-one, but it lands the boozy tobacco the original is loved for, and comes across stronger and more cognac-heavy. Reports on longevity contradict each other.
Ranking combines how widely wearers agree a fragrance is a dupe with how closely its notes and accords line up. “Strong match” means both signals agree; “loose match” means it is in the same family but noticeably different on skin.
Fragrance World Music Fest is widely sold as a dupe of Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club. Around 75 to 80 percent there — not a one-to-one, but it lands the boozy tobacco the original is loved for, and comes across stronger and more cognac-heavy. Reports on longevity contradict each other.
Fragrance World Music Fest is the closest we have on record. It is the one wearers name most consistently. Around 75 to 80 percent there — not a one-to-one, but it lands the boozy tobacco the original is loved for, and comes across stronger and more cognac-heavy. Reports on longevity contradict each other.
Yes, though only one: Fragrance World Music Fest. It is the only fragrance we have found a first-hand comparison for.
No. A dupe is built to the same idea, not the same formula, and cheaper materials usually show in the opening and in how long it lasts. That is why every entry here says how it differs instead of giving a percentage. Of Fragrance World Music Fest, for instance: Around 75 to 80 percent there — not a one-to-one, but it lands the boozy tobacco the original is loved for, and comes across stronger and more cognac-heavy. Reports on longevity contradict each other.
Rum and tobacco with vanilla underneath — warm, boozy, like an old bar at closing time.
Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club is a 2013 men's Eau de Toilette, and it is the most quietly successful thing in the Replica line.
The brief was a bar in Brooklyn, and it is followed closely. Rum and tobacco lead, with pink pepper and lemon on top for lift. Underneath there is vanilla, tonka and a soft leather, plus something faintly smoky that reads as a room where people have been smoking for years.
It is warm, boozy and comfortable rather than sharp or challenging. That is why it has stayed in production and stayed popular while flashier releases have come and gone.
Performance is moderate. It is an Eau de Toilette and behaves like one, sitting close after a few hours, which is arguably right for the concept.
Priced as accessible niche and sold widely, it is one of the few fragrances in this category where the original is not painful to buy. The clones exist anyway, mostly because the tobacco-vanilla accord is easy to get close to.